Wang Jianmin also has an extraordinary ability to control the quality of his shots in the field, in addition to lowering the number of home runs hit; Playing in front of the fielder, maybe there will be more grounders he is guarded. Therefore, regardless of the defensive rate on the books or advanced data such as FIP, Wang Jianmin may "only" be counted among the top 10 to top 30 pitchers in the league. But if we fully accept the narrative logic of the BR version—it is very difficult to throw a 3.7 RA/9 in 200 innings in front of the Yankees defense—then Wang Jianmin’s value may be the top five in MLB, or even the top three in the.
American League. , it seems impossible to telemarketing list find absolute evidence to refute it. Of course, the truth may also be somewhere between the two—it cannot be ruled out that Wang Jianmin may have a good dribble and a beautified defense rate in those two years; or maybe the Yankees fielders can expect a lot of grounders to appear in advance. Can come up with better defense. Therefore, the WAR calculated by the BR website certainly has the possibility of overestimating Wang Jianmin. But maybe FIP and xFIP data also underestimate him - considering that he may indeed produce more soft hits in the field than the average pitcher, just looking at strikeouts, walks, and home runs may be slightly insufficient.
Combining these perspectives, we are more certain that he is indeed a very good pitcher, and even has the possibility of being in the top ten in the league in his heyday. But at the same time, whether he ever reached the top five or even the top three in the league at that time is still a big unknown (although BR has hinted that this possibility exists). Take 2006 as an example, excluding Johan Santana who won the Cy Young Award, the American League pitchers who have won ERA, FIP and xFIP Wang Jianmin at the same time, as well as Roy Halladay, CCSabthia, Mike Mussina, Kelvim Escobar and others; John Lackey lost In xFIP, but also taking more games.